Cover of DOO-WOP, volume 6 of Origin Story

Origin Story  ·  Volume 6

DOO-WOP

How the Cheapest Music Ever Made Paid Everybody but the Singers, 1948–1962

Where it sits on the century

19151948–19622030
$14.99Paperback
about 120 pages

$13.49 each from three copies, $11.49 from sixteen, and $299.00 for all thirty-one with every ebook and audiobook included. Postage is free on every order over $79.

This is the complete story of doo-wop in about three hours: the acoustics of tile, and why the singers auditioned hallways the way later musicians auditioned amplifiers; the echo chamber — a bare concrete room with a loudspeaker at one end and a microphone at the other — that let the industry manufacture the stairwell and sell it back at ninety-eight cents a disc; the storefront labels where five kids sang between the desk and the filing cabinet and signed whatever was put in front of them; the garage in South Los Angeles that produced Earth Angel; the church basement in New Haven that produced In the Still of the Night; and the thirteen-year-old from Washington Heights who carried Why Do Fools Fall in Love around the world and died at twenty-five without his own writing credit.

It takes the money seriously, because this is the genre where the money is bleakest and best documented. Flat session fees against royalties that never arrived, and the Cadillac that was secretly an advance. Songwriting credits assigned to label owners, managers and disc jockeys, and the forty years of federal litigation that followed. Group names owned by businessmen who could — and did — fire the entire group and hire five strangers under the same marquee. A Zulu migrant worker whose improvised falsetto line became The Lion Sleeps Tonight, sold for ten shillings and settled with Disney sixty-seven years later. And the recovery: the aging singers who lived long enough to testify, the lawyer who took their cases for nothing, and the fraction that was finally clawed back.

Contains no song lyrics — and no transcribed vocables, in the one genre named after them. That is a deliberate rule, explained on the first page. What replaces them is a description of what five voices around one microphone were actually doing: the bass singing a drummer’s consonants, the falsetto detaching from the top of the chord, the blend that made five ordinary teenagers sound like one extraordinary instrument.

Format
Paperback
Trim
5.5 × 8.5 in
Pages
about 120
Chapters
25 in five movements
Period
1948–1962
Audiobook
2h 51m

The playlist

ORIGIN STORY: Doo-Wop — public, and sequenced to the order the records appear in Movement Three. The book describes them; the playlist plays them.

Volume 7
SOULthe corner group industrialised by its own alumni, with the publishing kept in the building
Volume 5
ROCK 'N' ROLLthe sibling story, sharing half this book’s cast and all of its machinery
Volume 8
THE BRITISH INVASIONthe harmony records posted back across the Atlantic, with interest

Free to read  ·  the opening

How volume 6 starts.

Origin Story · Volume 6 · DOO-WOPIntroduction

The Free Instrument

Every other volume in this series has to explain what its music cost. A guitar cost a month’s wages. A synthesiser cost a car. Studio time cost by the hour, pressing plants ran on minimums, and every one of those numbers decided who got to make the music and who did not.

This volume is different, and the difference is the whole subject. The music in this book cost nothing to make. The instrument was the human voice, which everybody already owned. The rehearsal room was a hallway, a stairwell, a subway station, a school lavatory, chosen, as we will see, with real acoustic sophistication, and free. The training was the church choir and the radio. A group needed no equipment, no van, no electricity. Four or five teenagers standing close together on a street corner were a complete, finished, performing act, and between roughly 1948 and 1962, in the Black neighbourhoods of the northern American cities and then well beyond them, tens of thousands of teenagers noticed.

That is the first fact about doo-wop, and it explains almost everything about the sound. The second fact explains almost everything about the story, and it is this: the music that cost nothing to make has now been earning money for more than seventy years, and for most of that time, almost none of the money reached the people who sang it.

The gap between those two numbers (zero at one end, seven decades of publishing royalties, reissues, film licences and oldies radio at the other) was occupied by adults. Managers who put their own names on songs written by fifteen-year-olds. Label owners who paid for a session once and collected on it forever. A businessman who ended up owning the copyright to the most famous teenage record ever made, and whose name is still, after three trials, on the credit. The story runs from a Baltimore stockroom girl who did it honestly to a New York operator convicted alongside organised crime, and it is better documented than the money story of any other genre in this series, because the people who were wronged lived long enough to sue, and many of them did, and the court records are public.

The introduction runs on for another 8 paragraphs, and then the book starts. 25 chapters · about 120 pages · $14.99

Contents

25 chapters, five movements.

Every volume in the series runs the same five, in this order. What each movement is for.

01The Room5 chapters
  1. 1The Hallway and the Corner
  2. 2Four Ways of Singing Together
  3. 3Baltimore, 1948
  4. 4The Neighbourhoods
  5. 5Who Was Actually on the Corner
02The Machine5 chapters
  1. 6The Sound of a Room
  2. 7The Independent Label
  3. 8The 45, the Jukebox and the Night Radio
  4. 9Three Hours, Four Songs
  5. 10How Five Voices Divide a Chord
03The Records6 chapters
  1. 111948–1953. Before It Had a Name
  2. 121954. The Year the Chart Broke
  3. 131955–1956. The Teenage Market
  4. 141957–1959. The Echo at Full Depth
  5. 151959–1962. The Genre Remembers Itself
  6. 16The Thousand Groups
04The Money5 chapters
  1. 17The Flat Fee and the Cadillac
  2. 18Whose Name Is on the Song
  3. 19Who Owned the Name
  4. 20Ten Shillings
  5. 21The Recovery
05The Ending4 chapters
  1. 22The Hearings
  2. 23The Lead Singer Walks
  3. 24The Revival That Never Ended
  4. 25The Echo, Continued

Free to read  ·  reference

DOO-WOP: the dates.

The book’s own timeline, in full and free to quote. 36 entries, 1948–1962. Where a date is contested the book says so at the point it appears; these are the ones that are not in serious dispute. All thirty-one timelines on one page.

1939
  • Johannesburg. Solomon Linda and the Evening Birds record Mbube at the Gallo studio. The improvised falsetto line will travel further than any melody in this book.
1947
  • Chicago, Peg o’ My Heart, cut at Bill Putnam’s Universal Recording with a bathroom as an echo chamber, demonstrates manufactured space to the American record industry.
  • New York, the Ravens put the bass voice out front.
1948
  • Memphis. WDIA pivots to Black-oriented programming; Black-appeal radio begins switching on nationally.
  • Baltimore. Deborah Chessler takes on the Vibra-Naires; renamed the Orioles, they record It’s Too Soon to Know. Number one on the race records chart; the span of this book opens.
1949
  • RCA introduces the seven-inch 45. Billboard renames its race records chart rhythm and blues.
1951
  • Cincinnati/New York, the Dominoes’ Sixty Minute Man, fourteen weeks at number one R&B, crosses into the pop top twenty.
  • Cleveland. Alan Freed begins his rhythm and blues radio show.
1952
  • March, the Moondog Coronation Ball is shut down by police almost as it begins, the crossover audience’s first public headcount.
  • The Weavers’ Wimoweh carries Solomon Linda’s melody into the American charts under a pseudonymous credit.
1953
  • Chicago/Gary. Vivian Carter and James Bracken found Vee-Jay, the era’s most significant Black-owned label. The Orioles’ Crying in the Chapel reaches the pop top fifteen. Clyde McPhatter leaves the Dominoes to found the Drifters.
1954
  • Spring, the Crows’ Gee crosses to the pop chart via West Coast radio.
  • June, the Chords’ Sh-Boom reaches the pop top ten; the Crew-Cuts’ cover takes number one within weeks, and the cover economy is running.
  • Autumn, the Penguins’ Earth Angel, cut in Ted Brinson’s garage, released on Dootone; the Moonglows’ Sincerely, with Alan Freed’s name in the writing credit, released on Chess. Freed moves to WINS, New York.
1955
  • The Platters sign to Mercury as the makeweight in the Penguins deal; Only You, then The Great Pretender, the first number one pop record by a group of this lineage.
1956
  • January, Why Do Fools Fall in Love; Frankie Lymon, thirteen, becomes the first Black teenage pop star. A settlement recognises Gaynel Hodge as co-author of Earth Angel.
  • February, the Five Satins record In the Still of the Night in a New Haven church-school basement.
1957
  • The Del-Vikings, racially integrated, reach the pop top five with Come Go with Me. The Gladiolas’ Little Darlin' is outsold many times over by the Diamonds’ cover; Maurice Williams, seventeen, keeps his writer’s credit. The Bobbettes chart with Mr. Lee. Sam Cooke leaves the Soul Stirrers.
1958
  • January, the Chantels’ Maybe, the writing credit reading George Goldner. The Silhouettes’ Get a Job reaches number one. The Elegants’ Little Star reaches number one; the group never charts again. George Treadwell dismisses the entire Drifters line-up and hires the Five Crowns under the name.
1959
  • The new Drifters’ There Goes My Baby, strings, baião rhythm, Ben E. King, reaches number two and points past the genre. The Flamingos’ I Only Have Eyes for You, the echo chamber’s masterpiece. November, the payola investigation opens; Freed is dismissed in New York.
1960
  • February, Jesse Belvin dies at twenty-seven after the first integrated show in Little Rock. Congress hears the payola testimony and amends the Communications Act. Ben E. King leaves the Drifters over a refused raise. November, Maurice Williams and the Zodiacs’ Stay, the shortest number one on record.
1961
  • The Marcels’ Blue Moon (number one), the Tokens’ The Lion Sleeps Tonight (number one), Little Caesar and the Romans’ Those Oldies But Goodies, the genre nostalgic for itself while still alive. In New York, the Times Square record shop anchors the collector scene that will name the genre.
1962
  • February. Gene Chandler’s Duke of Earl, cut by the Dukays, number one under a name invented for contractual reasons.
  • September. Solomon Linda dies in Soweto; his widow cannot immediately afford a headstone. The span of this book closes.
1965
  • Alan Freed dies at forty-three.
1966
  • Vee-Jay collapses.
1968
  • Frankie Lymon dies at twenty-five in Harlem.
1969
  • Richard Nader’s first Rock and Roll Revival at Madison Square Garden; Sha Na Na play Woodstock.
1972
  • WCBS-FM flips to oldies; Clyde McPhatter dies at thirty-nine.
1973
  • American Graffiti.
1981
  • Diana Ross’s cover returns Why Do Fools Fall in Love to the top ten, and the authorship wars begin in earnest.
1988
  • Atlantic settles with its pioneer artists; the Rhythm & Blues Foundation is founded; Morris Levy is convicted.
1992/1996
  • The Teenagers’ authorship verdict, won and reversed.
1999
  • The first PBS doo-wop reunion special.
2006
  • The Linda estate settles with Disney.
2012
  • Herb Reed’s rights to the Platters name are affirmed, weeks before his death.

Free to read  ·  where it comes from

The sources.

This series is written from published material and its byline claims method rather than credentials, so the sources are listed. They are given as books and categories of material rather than as page citations; where a claim in the text is contested, the text says so at the point of the claim.

A general caution applies to this volume more than to most, and the text has repeated it where it bites: the founding scenes of doo-wop were set down largely in interviews given thirty to fifty years after the fact, by participants recalling their own adolescence. Group memberships shifted constantly and are genuinely disputed; session dates and personnel at the storefront labels were poorly documented at the time and reconstructed later; and several of the genre’s standard stories (the Orioles’ broadcast audition, the writing of In the Still of the Night on guard duty, Buck Ram’s washroom, the Marcels’ borrowed introduction) rest substantially on a single participant’s own telling, repeated over decades, and are identified as such where they appear. Where the sung-syllable question arises, this book’s rule bears restating: song titles are quoted; no lyric and no sung vocable is transcribed anywhere in it.

Genre histories and reference. The Sound of the City, Charlie Gillett, still the foundational business-aware history of rock and roll’s rise, strong on the independent labels. Doowop: The Chicago Scene, Robert Pruter, the most rigorous scholarly study of a single scene, and a model of how to handle contested memory. The Complete Book of Doo-Wop, Anthony Gribin and Matthew Schiff, for the genre’s internal taxonomy. The group-by-group research of Marv Goldberg, published across decades in collector journals and online, is the closest thing the genre has to a census and underlies this book’s caution about line-ups. Jay Warner’s American Singing Groups for group chronologies.

The business. Hit Men, Fredric Dannen, for Morris Levy and the New York independents’ afterlife. Me, the Mob, and the Music, Tommy James with Martin Fitzpatrick, an artist’s-eye account of Roulette. Big Deal and standard music-business texts (Passman, All You Need to Know About the Music Business) for the publishing and recoupment mechanics, which are described in this book at period-appropriate rates. Ruth Brown’s memoir Miss Rhythm (with Andrew Yule) and contemporaneous press coverage of the Atlantic settlement and the founding of the Rhythm & Blues Foundation. Congressional records of the 1960 payola hearings (House Special Subcommittee on Legislative Oversight) for the disc-jockey economy. Reporting on the Truth in Music Advertising campaign, including legislative testimony by surviving group members.

The litigation. The Why Do Fools Fall in Love authorship case (Merchant and Santiago’s 1992 jury verdict and its 1996 reversal on appeal) and the parallel Lymon estate litigation are matters of federal and New York court record, extensively covered in the press of the day. The Solomon Linda chapter follows Rian Malan’s investigation In the Jungle (Rolling Stone, 2000), the subsequent 2004 South African proceedings against Disney, and the reported terms of the 2006 settlement; Malan’s reconstruction of the money is the essential source and is credited in the chapter itself. The Platters and Drifters name litigation is drawn from the published court decisions, including the 2012 federal ruling in favour of Herb Reed’s enterprise.

Participants’ accounts. Interview literature spanning five decades, including the oral histories collected by the Vocal Group Hall of Fame and the group-harmony fan press (Bim Bam Boom, Record Exchanger and successors); Frankie Lymon’s widely cited 1967 magazine interview on his addiction; the many late-life interviews of Deborah Chessler, Fred Parris, Maurice Williams, Terry Johnson, Harvey Fuqua, Herb Reed, Ben E. King and others, identified in the text as personal tellings where they carry weight alone. Berry Gordy’s memoir To Be Loved for the Motown hand-off.

The engineering. Standard histories of recording technology for the echo chamber, Bill Putnam and Universal Recording, Gold Star, and the EMT plate, including the technical press’s retrospectives on Putnam and the widely documented account of Peg o’ My Heart (1947). Chart positions and dates throughout are from the Billboard listings of the period (race records, rhythm and blues, and pop charts, under their changing names) via the standard compendia (Whitburn); UK positions from the Official Charts Company’s records.

Where figures are disputed (session costs, pressing counts, the size of flat fees, the precise authorship splits of Earth Angel and Why Do Fools Fall in Love, the balance of Solomon Linda’s estate) the text gives the range or the standard account and says whose account it is. Those disagreements are not gaps in the record. They are the record, and in this genre they are frequently the point.

What this book does not do

A short list of what is missing from this book, and why each absence is deliberate.

This book quotes no song lyrics. Not one line, not one phrase, and in this volume the rule reaches further than usual, because this is a genre named after its own backing vocals, and the nonsense syllables sung on these records are as much the song as the words are. So none of them are transcribed here either. That is a deliberate rule and it is absolute, and song lyrics are owned, licensing them is negotiated song by song and publisher by publisher, and there is no safe word count: the copyright office says so in as many words. A book that quotes a little is a book making a legal judgement it cannot check. This one quotes none, and instead does the harder and more interesting thing, which is to tell you what five voices standing around one microphone were actually doing.

It reproduces no album art and no photographs. There is nothing to look at here but words and one flat poster on the cover.

And it cannot play you a record, which is the real limitation, and there is no point pretending otherwise. What it can do is point. There is a playlist for this book, on the same app you may well be reading or listening to it on, sequenced to the chapters, and its name is at the end of the introduction and again at the end of the book. Read the chapter, then play the record. The description will tell you what to listen for; the record will do the rest.

Shelved under

MUSIC / History & Criticism  ·  MUSIC / Genres & Styles / Soul & R 'n B  ·  MUSIC / Business Aspects

Identifiers

Ebook ISBN
979-8-90623-885-6
Audiobook ISBN
979-8-90623-886-3
Paperback ISBN
not yet issued

Buy it

Paperback, $14.99, posted direct. Every ebook and audiobook comes free with the complete set.

Questions

About this volume.

What is Origin Story volume 6 about?

How the Cheapest Music Ever Made Paid Everybody but the Singers, 1948–1962. The cheapest music ever made cost nothing at all. The instrument was the human voice, which everybody already owned; the rehearsal room was a tenement hallway, a stairwell, a subway station — chosen by ear, for the echo; the training was the church choir and the radio. Between 1948 and 1962, in the Black neighbourhoods the Great Migration built, tens of thousands of teenagers discovered that four or five voices on a street corner were a complete, finished band. Then the record business discovered the teenagers.

What years does DOO-WOP cover?

1948–1962. The volume is numbered 6 because that is where the genre sits in the chronology of the music, not the order the books were written in — the first three written were volumes 17, 19 and 21.

What made DOO-WOP possible?

The echo chamber. Movement Two of every volume is about the technology that made the genre possible and would not have ten years earlier.

Are there song lyrics in it?

None. Not one line, in this volume or in any of the thirty-one. Lyrics are copyrighted expression, licensing is negotiated song by song and publisher by publisher, and there is no safe quantity — so the rule is zero, and a program checks the manuscript, the EPUB and the narration script against it before the volume ships. What replaces them is a description of what the record actually sounds like, what it cost, and who was paid.

How long is it?

About 28,500 words: 25 chapters across five movements, roughly 120 minutes’ reading, 120 pages in the paperback. The audiobook runs 2h 51m.

What is in the back of the book?

A dated timeline of 36 entries, a source list, and a note on what the volume does not do. All three are reproduced free on this page.

Can I buy DOO-WOP in print?

Yes, here. It is a 5.5 × 8.5 in paperback, 60# uncoated cream, black ink, about 120 pages, and it never goes out of print.